Home › Blog › Fall Garden Bed Cleanup: What to Cut Back and What to Leave

Fall Garden Bed Cleanup: What to Cut Back and What to Leave

Published November 19, 2026 · By Old Mill Nurseries

On Long Island, cut back perennials that collapse or carry disease after the first frosts, such as hostas, daylilies, peonies and bearded iris. Leave ornamental grasses, seed-bearing perennials, bigleaf hydrangeas and woody herbs like lavender standing until spring. Clear leaves out of beds and off the lawn before winter, and skip the fertilizer.

Why not just cut everything to the ground?

A bare, tidy bed looks finished, but it isn't always healthier. Many plants protect their own crowns with their old stems, and some set next year's flowers on growth that's already there.

Standing stems and seed heads also feed birds and shelter beneficial insects through the winter. The goal of a fall cleanup is to remove what causes problems, not everything that looks tired.

When should you do a fall cleanup on Long Island?

After the first few frosts, once perennials have turned brown and gone dormant. On the South Shore, in towns like Bellmore, Merrick and Wantagh, that's usually mid-November into early December. Inland and North Shore yards often get there a week or two sooner.

You don't need to rush. Cutting perennials back while they're still green takes away energy they're storing in their roots for spring.

What should you cut back in fall?

  • Hostas and daylilies. After a frost their leaves turn to mush, and that mush gives slugs and their eggs a place to spend the winter.
  • Peonies. Cut the stems to the ground. Peony leaves often carry fungal disease, and removing them keeps it from coming back next year.
  • Bearded iris. Trim the leaves to a few inches. Iris borers lay their eggs on old foliage, and taking it away breaks their cycle.
  • Plants with mildew or leaf spot, such as garden phlox and bee balm. Bag those clippings rather than composting them.
  • Annuals. Pull them out once frost has killed them, roots and all.

What should you leave standing until spring?

  • Ornamental grasses. They hold their shape through winter, catch snow nicely, and protect their own crowns. Cut them down in March before new growth starts.
  • Sedum, coneflowers and black-eyed Susans. Their seed heads feed goldfinches and other birds, and they add structure to a bare winter bed.
  • Bigleaf hydrangeas. The blue and pink types common on Long Island bloom on last year's stems. Cutting them now means no flowers next summer. Panicle and smooth hydrangeas bloom on new wood and can be pruned in late winter.
  • Lavender, Russian sage and butterfly bush. These woody plants recover better from a spring pruning than a fall one.
  • Evergreen perennials, such as hellebores and heuchera. Just tidy any damaged leaves.

What about the leaves?

Get leaves off the lawn and out of the crowns of your perennials. A wet mat of leaves smothers grass and holds moisture against plant crowns, which leads to rot.

Leaves don't have to go to waste. Shredded leaves make a good winter mulch on beds, as long as they're spread thin and kept a few inches back from stems.

Should you mulch or fertilize in fall?

A thin layer of mulch after the ground starts to cool helps protect roots from freeze-and-thaw cycles. Keep it away from tree trunks and shrub stems.

Skip the fertilizer. Nassau County restricts lawn fertilizer from November 15 to April 1, and Suffolk from November 1 to April 1. Plants going dormant can't use it anyway, and it washes into the bays.

What else should be on a fall checklist?

  • Winterize your sprinklers before the first hard freeze (see our guide to sprinkler blowouts).
  • Protect young evergreens from winter wind and salt spray, especially near the water.
  • Clean and store hoses and empty planters that can crack in a freeze.
  • Note gaps in your beds now, while you remember them, so spring planting is easier.

Can you hire someone to do it?

Yes. A fall cleanup takes most homeowners a full weekend or more, plus hauling bags of debris. Old Mill's crews cut back what should come down, leave what should stay, clear leaves from beds and lawn, and haul everything away.

Frequently asked questions

When should I cut back perennials on Long Island?

After the first few frosts, once the plants have browned and gone dormant, usually mid-November into early December.

Should I cut back ornamental grasses in fall?

No. Leave them standing for winter interest and crown protection, and cut them down in March before new growth starts.

Should I prune hydrangeas in fall?

Not the blue and pink bigleaf types. They bloom on last year's stems, so fall pruning removes next summer's flowers.

Is it okay to leave leaves in garden beds?

A thin layer of shredded leaves works as mulch. Thick, wet mats should be cleared out of plant crowns and off the lawn.

Can I fertilize my lawn in late fall on Long Island?

No. Nassau County restricts fertilizer from November 15 to April 1, and Suffolk from November 1 to April 1.

Book your fall cleanup

Old Mill Nurseries' crews handle fall cleanups across Nassau County and western Suffolk. Request a free estimate or call (516) 271-1886.

Request a Free Estimate

About Old Mill Nurseries: a family business in Bellmore, NY, serving Long Island homeowners since 1999.

  • WHY CALL US

    At Old Mill we offer things no other nursery offers. We specialize in plants, trees, shrubs, flowers, landscape design, topsoil, mulch, sprinklers, outdoor lighting & audio, tick & mosquito control & more.
  • CALL FOR ADVICE

    Most homeowners and business owners are unsure what to do with certain areas of their property. At Old Mill Nurseries we have a large team of experts waiting to help. Call us today to talk about your project.
  • INSTALLATIONS

    Besides our amazing prices we also install what we sell. We make it easy for our customers by installing & guaranteeing our products. We also advise you what would be a good fit for your home or business.
  • BEST PRICES

    What we don’t grow we buy in bulk and pass the savings on to our thousands of customers. Our buying power allows us to source the finest plants, trees & shrubs throughout the United States for our clients.